Comparison of 29 High-Impact Style Decisions Across Leading Manuals
- Serial (Oxford) comma
- Headline & title capitalization
- "Spell-out" threshold for numbers
- Month-day-year dates
- Percent sign vs. percent
- Punctuation inside quotation marks
- Em-dash spacing
- Ellipses spacing
- Titles of works: italics vs. quotes
- Citation systems
- Capital after a colon
- Singular they
- State abbreviations
- Compound-modifier hyphens
- U.S. / US / United States
- Academic-degree punctuation
- Time-of-day format
- Number-range style
- Month abbreviations
- Job-title capitalization
- internet / web capitalization
- Courtesy titles (Mr., Ms.)
- Foreign-word italics
- Possessives of names ending in S
- Periods in initialisms
- Bulleted-list punctuation
- Split infinitives
- & in company names
- Numerals before “million”
Serial (Oxford) Comma
- NYT – Drop it in simple series; restore only if needed for clarity. Example:
red, white and blue. - AP – Identical to NYT; clarity overrides rule.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Always keep:
red, white, and blue. Reasoning: prevents mis-grouping of the last two items.
Headline & Title Capitalization
- NYT – Title-case headlines; capitalize all verbs, prepositions ≥4 letters, pronouns; lowercase articles and short conjunctions.
- AP – Same uppercase pattern in headlines; but uses sentence-case for non-headline composition titles.
- Chicago / MLA – Headline-style titles; lowercase all prepositions ≤4 letters (Chicago 18e now capitalizes longer ones).
- APA – Title-case for journal titles; sentence-case for article titles.
Spell-Out Threshold for Numbers
- NYT – Spell out one through nine; use numerals 10+.
- AP – Same baseline; many numeric beats (age, percent, dates) are always figures.
- Chicago – Spell out zero – one hundred; numerals above, except in technical copy.
- APA / MLA – Numerals for 10+ (APA) or > two-word length (MLA); contextual exceptions for statistics.
Month-Day-Year Dates
- NYT & AP – Jan. 4, 2025; abbreviate Jan., Feb., Aug., Sept., Oct., Nov., Dec.; no th.
- Chicago – January 4, 2025 in running text; ISO (2025-01-04) allowed in data contexts.
- APA – Text rarely needs full dates; citations use (2025, January 4).
Percent Sign vs. percent
- NYT / AP – Since 2019, always use the symbol with a numeral: 7%; spell out at sentence start.
- Chicago – In prose, 7 percent; symbol reserved for scientific/statistical contexts.
- APA – Symbol after numerals; word after spelled-out numbers (seven percent).
Punctuation Inside Quotation Marks
- NYT / AP / Chicago – Comma & period go inside the closing quote in American English.
- APA / MLA – Follow Chicago rule; question/colon/semicolon placement depends on logic.
Em-Dash Spacing
- NYT / AP – Insert a space on both sides:
word — word. - Chicago / APA / MLA – Closed em-dash:
word—word. - Rationale: Newspapers prefer loose tracking for narrow columns; book style favors tighter setting.
Ellipses Spacing
- NYT / AP – Space on each side of three points:
word … word. - Chicago – Space before/after; uses four-dot version when ellipsis ends a sentence.
- APA / MLA – Same as Chicago for scholarly quotation.
Titles of Works: Italics vs. Quotes
- NYT / AP – No italics; put most works in quotation marks:
"Hamlet"
. - Chicago / MLA / APA – Italicize stand-alone works (Hamlet), quote shorter pieces or chapters.
Citation Systems
- NYT / AP – Journalistic attribution in running prose; no parenthetical system.
- Chicago – Two systems: notes-bibliography or author-date.
- APA – Author-date only.
- MLA – Author-page parenthetical.
Capitalization After a Colon
- NYT / AP – Capitalize if what follows is a full sentence.
- Chicago – Lowercase unless colon introduces two + complete sentences or a quotation.
- APA / MLA – Follow Chicago rule.
Singular they
- NYT / AP – Acceptable sparingly when re-wording is clumsy or when a person requests it.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Fully endorsed for both generic and non-binary reference.
U.S. State Abbreviations
- NYT / AP – Traditional abbreviations in datelines only (Ala., Ind.); spell out elsewhere.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – USPS two-letter codes (AL, IN) or full state names in text.
Compound-Modifier Hyphens
- NYT / AP – Hyphenate before a noun unless term is familiar & unambiguous (
high school student
butfull-time job
); 2019 update loosened rule. - Chicago / APA / MLA – Hyphenate adjectival compounds before noun; drop after noun.
United States Abbreviation
- NYT / AP – U.S. in text; US in headlines.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Either U.S. or spelled-out; avoid abbreviation as adjective in formal prose.
Academic-Degree Punctuation
- NYT / AP – No periods in most degrees (PhD, MA).
- Chicago – Periods optional; house preference often Ph.D..
- APA / MLA – Periods typically omitted.
Time-of-Day Format
- NYT / AP – 9 a.m.; drop minutes if :00; use noon/midnight.
- Chicago – 9:00 a.m. in text; spell out in narrative (
nine o'clock
). - APA / MLA – Follows Chicago numeric form.
Number-Range Style
- NYT / AP – Use hyphen: 8-10 p.m.; spell
to
if second unit has a.m./p.m. switch. - Chicago / APA / MLA – En dash for ranges: pp. 215–18.
Month Abbreviations
- NYT / AP – Jan., Feb., Aug., Sept., Oct., Nov., Dec. when a specific date follows.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Spell months in running text.
Job-Title Capitalization
- NYT / AP – Capitalize formal title before name (
President Biden
); lowercase after (Joe Biden, president
). - Chicago / APA / MLA – Same rule, but academic titles often lowercase even before name (
professor Jane Smith
).
internet / web Capitalization
- All five – Since 2016–17, lowercase internet and web unless part of a proper noun.
Courtesy Titles (Mr., Ms.)
- NYT – Retains courtesy titles on second reference in most hard-news copy; dropping them in pop-culture desks.
- AP / Chicago / APA / MLA – Generally omit; use only in quotes or when distinction required.
Foreign-Word Italics
- NYT / AP – AP never uses italics; enclose unfamiliar foreign terms in quotes and define.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Italicize first appearance of an unfamiliar term; roman thereafter if repeated.
Possessives of Names Ending in s
- NYT / AP – Singular proper name: add only apostrophe (
Dickens' novel
). - Chicago / APA / MLA – Add 's:
Dickens's novel
; pronunciation guides choice.
Periods in Initialisms
- NYT / AP – Use periods in two-letter abbreviations (U.S., U.N.); drop for three + letters (NASA).
- Chicago – Period style varies; many caps abbreviations omit periods (NATO), but academic initialisms may keep them (U.S.).
- APA / MLA – Follow Chicago; period after each letter in measured units only if lowercase.
Bulleted-List Punctuation
- NYT / AP – Capitalize first word. End with period if list item is a sentence; no punctuation for single words/phrases.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Same; Chicago allows semicolon-style run-on lists when lead-in stem requires.
Split Infinitives
- NYT / AP – Permitted when avoiding awkwardness:
to boldly go
. - Chicago / APA / MLA – No blanket ban; prefer clarity and natural rhythm.
Ampersand in Company Names
- All guides – Keep ampersand only if the organization's legal name uses it (
AT&T
,Procter & Gamble
). Otherwise use and.
Numerals Before “Million”
- NYT / AP – Figure-word combo: 2 million, $4.3 billion.
- Chicago / APA / MLA – Same combo; Chicago spells out
two million
only at sentence start.